You’ve probably taken a thousand penalty kicks in your life. And you’ve made hundreds — whether in a game, in practice, or just in the backyard.
But this one feels different. It’s a playoff game, and the 12 yards between you and the net are the difference between the end of your season and a trip to the state championship.
You know the stakes. Your body does, too. You’re shaking. Your palms are sweaty and cold. You’re more aware of your heartbeat than you’ve been all night. And there’s a small, quiet impulse reminding you that you could walk back to the sideline and all this pressure would go away.
All of this is normal. Understanding what you’re experiencing, and knowing what to do with it, is the key.
Performance Anxiety Is Real
High school athletes face pressure from all directions. You might want to impress a college coach, live up to your parents’ expectations, or avoid letting your teammates down. After months of preparation, it can feel like everything comes down to one moment.
Anxiety affects more than your thoughts. Your heart rate increases, your muscles tense, and your mind starts racing. That’s your body’s natural fight-or-flight response. In small doses, it can help you stay alert. When it becomes overwhelming, though, it can interfere with concentration, decision-making, and performance.
Feeling nervous before a big game doesn’t mean something is wrong with you. But when fear of failure keeps you from playing freely, enjoying your sport, or performing the way you know you can, it’s worth paying attention.
Understanding Your Emotions Can Make You a Better Athlete
The goal isn’t to eliminate anxiety. It’s to learn how to respond to it.
Start by recognizing what you’re feeling instead of trying to ignore it. You might be nervous, frustrated, or afraid of making a mistake. Naming that emotion can help you respond more intentionally rather than letting it dictate your actions.
Pay attention to the thoughts accompanying those feelings, too. Anxiety often turns uncertainty into catastrophe — If I miss this kick, I’ll let everyone down. If I have a bad game, the coach will never trust me again.
These thoughts can feel convincing without being entirely true. Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), an approach often used in counseling, helps people identify unhelpful thought patterns and evaluate them more realistically. Instead of telling yourself you can’t make a mistake, remind yourself that you’ve practiced for this moment and can focus on the next step.
Simple strategies can help, too. Slow your breathing, establish a consistent pregame routine, and focus on something you can control. During a game, a cue like “next play” can help redirect your attention from a previous mistake to the task in front of you. Here are some more strategies to help calm your thoughts.
Understanding your emotions doesn’t make you less competitive. It gives you more control over how you respond under pressure.
It’s Okay to Fail
Here’s something every athlete needs to hear: You will fail sometimes.
You’ll miss the penalty kick, strike out with runners on base, turn the ball over, or run a slower race than you wanted. Preparation and confidence can’t guarantee a perfect outcome.
The problem comes when a mistake becomes a judgment about who you are. There’s a difference between thinking, I missed that shot, and thinking, I’m a terrible player. One recognizes an outcome; the other turns it into an identity.
When your self-worth depends on performing well, every mistake can feel like a threat. That pressure can make it harder to take risks, learn from feedback, and enjoy the sport in the first place.
Healthy ambition means working to improve while recognizing that your performance doesn’t determine your value. You can take your goals seriously without expecting perfection. In fact, learning to recover from mistakes is part of becoming a better athlete.
Learning to Handle the Pressure
Start by noticing when anxiety shows up and how it affects you. Practice breathing and focusing on controllable goals. Talk with a trusted coach or parent about what you’re experiencing rather than assuming you have to manage it alone.
If anxiety regularly interferes with your performance, enjoyment of sports, or life outside athletics, a counselor can help you develop practical coping skills and work through the thoughts and fears contributing to the pressure.
We’re Here to Help
At Peace Family Counseling, we’re passionate about helping adolescents and young adults navigate anxiety, stress, and the challenges of growing up. Athletes deserve support not only in pursuing their goals, but also in developing a healthy relationship with achievement, failure, and their own sense of worth. If you or your family are navigating these challenges, we’d be honored to connect with you.
To get started, you can either reach out to schedule an appointment or set up a free 15-minute phone call with our Intake Coordinator here. We’re located in Greenwood and Martinsville, serving the Southside of Indianapolis, and we’re here to help your family find healing and hope.
And sometimes, even after all that preparation, you’ll still miss the kick. That’s okay, too. Your season, your potential, and your worth as a person are bigger than one moment.
About the Author:

Jeff Griffith, LMHCA
Therapist
Jeff Griffith, LMHCA, helps musicians, high-achievers, and digital-age clients move from pressure and stuck to grounded and purposeful.
Using evidence-based practices like CBT and DBT, he helps build both insight and practical tools to support sustainable growth. Currently accepting new clients.



